On August 13th at Merkin Hall, conductor Marlon Daniel and his “Ensemble du Monde” performed Beethoven’s third, fourth and fifth piano concerti. I heard through the grapevine that all five concerti were originally planned. That would have provided more contrast because the first two concertos (especially the second in B-flat) are lighter than the final three, which—when heard together—tend to overdose us with Beethoven’s middle-period drama and heftiness of orchestration. In other words, if you’re going to do several Beethoven Piano Concertos, do the second, first (in correct composing order) and third on one program, and the fourth and fifth on another.
The fine pianist in the third concerto, Richard Dowling, played very well. He occasionally tossed off a bland phrase or two, but that may be my own predisposition to preferring dramatic “Sturm und Drang” performances of this C Minor composition. In the fourth concerto, Kimball Gallagher played with a pleasant tone throughout (although I thought the opening solo phrase was too loud). Sometimes, she needed more invention of shading and dynamics in this work’s tender more tender passages. It was enjoyable nonetheless.
The pianist in the “Emperor” Concerto, Beatrice Long, has a bravura temperament and technique suitable for this large-scale, heroic work, and she displayed musical excellence by bringing out nuances and important harmonic changes in the score. Her phrasing showed admirable shape and contrast; when, for example, a scale passage ascended, there was a slight crescendo to show the direction of the musical line, and vice versa with descending phrases. I wish she had taken the Adagio un poco mosso movement slower; Adagio un poco mosso, after all, means slow with a little forward movement. It should not sound like a Beethoven Andante, which translates to a walking, moderate pace.
Conductor Marlon Daniel has talent and great energy. He does need to watch his concentration; in the Largo of the third concerto, he gave a cue two bars too soon (luckily, the orchestra didn’t come in), and there were some shaky entrances and small lapses of ensemble. I recommend that he keep the volume of the trumpets and timpani down at Merkin Hall, as there was consistent blaring in the concerti’s outer movements. Still, Daniel and his orchestra have potential, and I would like to hear them again.
