Distinguished Concerts International New York (DCINY) presents Carmina Burana in Review
Jonathan Griffith, DCINY Artistic director/principal conductor
Penelope Shumate, soprano; William Ferguson, tenor; Rob McGinness, baritone
Tzu-Yi Chen, Jeremy Filsell, pianists
Greg Gilpin, composer/conductor
Kelly Yu-Chien Lin, piano
Distinguished Concerts Singers International
Stern Auditorium at Carnegie Hall, New York, NY
June 6, 2022
Distinguished Concerts International New York (DCINY) continued the return towards “normalcy” in the concert world of New York with the June 6th presentation of Carmina Burana, paired with an opening act filled by works written for and performed by middle school (ages 11-13) singers. The Distinguished Concerts Singers International came from Maine, Georgia, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Kentucky, New Jersey, New York, Mexico, France, and Hong Kong. I was delighted about the international contingent, another step towards the pre-pandemic days.
Gilpin: Music for Middle School Voices was the opening portion of the program. Fifty-three youngsters took the stage to offer six selections written with the abilities of the middle school singer in mind (the title is somewhat a misnomer, as only two of the works were by Mr. Gilpin) As is common for this age group, the young ladies outnumbered the young men in a ratio of approximately 4:1. Pianist Kelly Yu-Chien Lin was the accompanist.
Greg Gilpin, in his 6th appearance with DCINY, conducted/coached the young singers. He projects an avuncular air, which is ideal for performers of this level and age. The energy he radiated was returned in abundance that must have filled him with pride. For the sake of completeness, the works performed were Festival Sanctus, Come to Me, O My Love, Shenandoah, Dry Bones, and the two Gilpin works: For the Beauty of the Earth, and Why We Sing.
Groups of this type present an interesting challenge for the reviewer. It would be inappropriate (and mean-spirited) to judge them with the standards one would use for older/more experienced ensembles. I suspect that Mr. Gilpin might have been reading my mind – “We are not aiming for perfection, but rather sharing joy,” was the gist of his spoken comments from the stage. Was it perfect? Of course not. Was it joyful? Absolutely! Who knows what future stars of the singing world were on that stage tonight, but one does know that this was the experience of a lifetime that will be with these youngsters forever. That idea is one that I never tire of, and the families and friends can be justly proud of their stars. Kudos to the “home” directors for prepping their singers and for the dedication they show each day in teaching these youngsters. They are unsung heroes.
Carl Orff’s Carmina Burana occupied the entire second part of the program. It’s one of those works (specifically O Fortuna) that everyone “knows” without knowing the title or composer. It’s been used so many times in popular culture as to almost become cliché.
Orff wrote in a 1937 letter to his publisher, “Everything I have written to date, and which you have, unfortunately, printed, can be destroyed. With Carmina Burana, my collected works begin.” One could add and here they end, as nothing that Orff wrote after it remotely approached the popularity of Carmina Burana. Despite the obvious erotic source material, the dreaded designation Entartete Musik (degenerate music) bypassed Carmina Burana, no doubt due to the composer’s political and racial acceptability to the regime. The program notes suggest that Orff would be a finalist in a contest for a composer with the most despicable character; fair enough, but some scholars have suggested things are not as black-and-white as they seem.
It was not stated explicitly in the program, but this performance used the 1956 reduced version (authorized by Orff) for soloists, SATB mixed choir, children’s choir, two pianos and six percussionists by Orff’s disciple Wilhelm Killmayer. This allows smaller ensembles to stage the work. It’s an effective arrangement, but it obviously cannot match the grandeur of the sound of the huge orchestra in the original (especially the opening O Fortuna).
Enough of the history, let’s get to the performance. This is far from this listener’s first Carmina Burana, so how did it compare? Despite my initial skepticism about this version, I was quickly won over by the tautness of conception and the unflagging energy. Whatever was lost in power from the small forces was more than compensated in the high-octane enthusiasm of the outstanding pianists Tzu-Yi Chen and Jeremy Filsell and six young (unnamed) percussionists. The three vocal soloists all brought their A-game to the stage, with voices that could fill any hall without any strain or stridency. There is much to praise, but I will limit myself to highlights for each. The radiant voice of soprano Penelope Shumate (a DCINY favorite) was always at the forefront, but her foray into the stratosphere in the Dulcissime (Sweetest Boy) was breathtaking. Tenor William Ferguson’s sad lament of the doomed swan in Olim lacus colueram (Once I Swan in Lakes) projected a subtle comic irony that others have “forced” on the listener with some histrionics and facial mugging. Finally, baritone Rob McGinness delivered the self-important bluster of Ego sum abbas (“I am the abbot” – of Cockaigne) with gusto that had the audience laughing as he wandered the stage. Let’s not forget the large chorus, who were well-prepared and ready to shine, which they most certainly did.
Maestro Jonathan Griffith led with his customary sure hand. It may have been two years away, but he has lost none of his mastery, and it was a treat to enjoy his work once again. The audience gave all the performers a well-deserved loud, extended standing ovation at the end.
