Distinguished Concerts Orchestra; Distinguished Concerts Singers International
James M. Meaders, DCINY conductor; Jean-Sébastien Vallée, guest conductor
Maribeth Crawford, soprano; Cecelia Stearman, mezzo-soprano; Shawn Mlynek, tenor; Patton Rice, bass
Stern Auditorium at Carnegie Hall, New York, NY
February 19. 2018
Distinguished Concerts International New York (DCINY), now in their 10th season, has made the “themed concert” a staple of their programming. A particular favorite of DCINY is a format featuring two requiems, either introducing a newer work with one of the classics, or both being well known and well-loved offerings. On this occasion, the latter combination was used. In a concert entitled Perpetual Light, the Requiems of Mozart and Duruflé were to be featured. The Distinguished Concerts Singers International personnel hailed from California, Louisiana, Mississippi, Oregon, Tennessee, Virginia, Wyoming, Canada, Germany, The Netherlands, and the United Kingdom, and also included individual singers from elsewhere around the globe.
Mozart’s Requiem in D minor, K. 626 has a storied history. Commissioned by Count Franz von Walsegg as a memorial to his late wife, it was unfinished by Mozart at the time of his death in 1791. His student Franz Xaver Süssmayr completed the work, relying on various sketches as well as his own assumptions of familiarity with Mozart’s wishes for the composition. How much of the work is Mozart versus how much is Süssmayr is still being debated to this day, but this a task best left to the musical forensics experts.
James M. Meaders took the podium to conduct. His approach was assured, but with what seemed to be a special emphasis on restraint. The “fire and brimstone” that abounds in this work never became overblown. It simmered under the surface, which made the listener feel as if a soul were in the balance and that Heavenly Judges were weighing the evidence with the utmost severity. Mr. Meaders proved to be a musician who understands that Mozart has provided all the drama necessary – it was all very compelling. One was left with the uneasy feeling at the end that judgment was still forthcoming. This listener found it all quite gripping.
Some words of praise for the soloists, both as individuals and as an ensemble, are in order here. Soprano Maribeth Crawford sang with a soaring brilliance. Mezzo-soprano Cecelia Stearman’s lovely voice delighted. Tenor Shawn Mlynek sang with striking projection, and bass Patton Rice’s strong voice was appropriately imposing. One must not forget the (unnamed) trombone soloist in the Tuba Mirum for her flawless playing.
After intermission, guest conductor Jean-Sébastien Vallée took to the podium to conduct the Requiem, Op. 9, of French organist, pedagogue, and composer, Maurice Duruflé (1902-1986). Modeled after Gabriel Fauré’s Requiem, this serene work is the polar opposite of the Mozart. It is devoid of some of the fearsome elements of the requiem mass and omits the Dies Irae. While I am continually awestruck by the genius of Mozart’s work, I feel that Duruflé’s conception is more in the spirit of a final mass that is asking for a peaceful eternal rest.
Mr. Vallée took an expansive approach, bringing out all the beauty that abounds in this wonderful work. He was a passionate leader, with sweeping gestures to the large chorus to exhort them to “sing to the heavens.” His approach was to pay off handsomely. This listener counts this work among his favorite Requiems and was enthralled with this performance. There is so much to praise that I will limit myself to a favorite – it is always a thrill to hear the bold Domine Jesu Christe burst forth with its majesty.
Mezzo-soprano Cecelia Stearman’s Pie Jesu was stunningly beautiful, and the power of bass Patton Rice’s voice filled the hall in the Libera Me.
As the final notes of the In Paradisum faded to silence, the judgment was rendered and the doors of Heaven opened. The silence in the hall held for a moment as if the audience felt this great relief before bursting into a standing ovation. Congratulations to all!
