Shattered Glass Ensemble in Review

Rondo Music Society presents
Shattered Glass Ensemble
Elizabeth Woo, violin soloist
Zankel Hall, Carnegie Hall; New York, NY
May 7, 2013
 
Shattered Glass  Ensemble at Carnegie Hall

Shattered Glass Ensemble at Carnegie Hall; photo credit: Brian Hatton

 

Shattered Glass, a sixteen member string orchestra sans conductor, is very much a product of the 21st century -marketing themselves with a professionally produced website and all the elements of social media (Facebook, Twitter, YouTube, and Instagram). The players hail from all around the globe, but they all met and joined together while attending the Manhattan School of Music. In addition to having a wide mainstream repertoire, Shattered Glass has been active in crossover collaborations with pop and hip-hop artists. Mentored by the noted violinist, teacher, and composer Albert Markov, this group is poised to make its mark on the music world by reaching out to as wide an audience as possible.

Violinist Elizabeth Woo, artistic director of Shattered Glass and highly acclaimed artist in her own right, headlined a program featuring her as a soloist in works by Vivaldi, Sarasate, and Albert Markov. The program opened with the Concerto for Three Violins in F major, RV 551 of Vivaldi, with violin soloists Elizabeth Woo, Holly Jenkins, and Tina Bouey.  The opening Allegro movement got off to a problematic start, with intermittent intonation issues and tentative playing. The question that arose was whether this was something borne of nerves or was it going to be an endemic problem throughout.  The answer was forthcoming in the Andante, where the playing was solid, and the final Allegro, which proved that any jitters were gone. The playing was confident, with good ensemble balance and precise intonation. The second work, the Ricercar a 6 from The Musical Offering by J.S. Bach was composed on what amounted to a challenge by Frederick the Great.  On May 7, 1747, Frederick gave Bach a theme with the task to improvise a three-part fugue on the spot.  When Bach made short work of that, Frederick demanded a six-part fugue. Bach asked leave to write out the work and The Musical Offering was the end result.  On the 266th anniversary of this meeting, Shattered Glass played the Ricercar a 6 in an arrangement by young composer Qin Dang for twelve players  (six violins, three violas, two cellos, and a double-bass). Her arrangement uses as inspiration Anton Webern’s Klangfarbenmelodie approach to the same work (though the latter included winds, brass, and harp). As violist Michael Davis said in his comments before playing, “making connections is the biggest challenge,” in the work. That challenge was successfully met – the interplay between the twelve musicians was excellent; at no time was any single player dominating over the others in what was a perfect rendering of the Klangfarbenmelodie style. To end the first half, Shattered Glass offered the String Symphony No. 7 in D minor, MWV N 7, a remarkably mature work composed by Felix Mendelssohn at the age of thirteen (!).  For the first time, all sixteen players took to the stage. Bass player Max Jacob provided a moment of levity when he abruptly hustled off the stage only to return a moment later with a huge grin and his missing bow, much to the amusement of the audience.  Now that all players were properly equipped, they launched into a spirited reading. The precision of attack in the opening Allegro and superb dynamic control, especially the pianissimos in the Andante,  were striking. The playful, almost sinister colors of the Menuetto and finally the energetic Allegro molto contributed to a winning performance.

Sinfonietta Per Archi ( Sinfonietta No. 1 for Strings), composed in 1992 by Krzysztof Penderecki (b. 1933), opened the second half. This work alternates from the strident to the nostalgic throughout while making virtuosic demands in both solo and ensemble. Shattered Glass seems to possess a particular affinity for this work. The playing was exceptional from start to finish in what was the highlight of the concert to this listener. Special mention must be made of the soloists; violinist Elizabeth Woo, violist Celia Hatton, and cellist Grace Ho for their exceptional playing. After the thorny Penderecki, Pablo de Sarasate’s Spanish Dances – Playera, Zapateado, and Habanera, were a surefire way to lighten the mood. In an arrangement by Mr. Markov where the piano accompaniment was transcribed for strings, Elizabeth Woo took center stage in the soloist’s role.  Ms. Woo has the requisite technique and gave these crowd-pleasing works a virtuosic performance. The large and enthusiastic audience roared its approval. As much as I detest histrionics and admire control, I found myself wishing for a bit less restraint from Ms. Woo. To close, Ms. Woo performed the world premiere of Rhapsody No. 6, “Korean”, written especially for her by her teacher Albert Markov (b.1933). Inspired by a visit to Gangwon Province in South Korea,  this work uses traditional Korean folk melodies in an “East meets West” fashion. Ms. Woo was a shining star in this highly effective and charming work. The audience responded with a standing ovation for Ms. Woo, Mr. Markov, and the ensemble. This work will no doubt become a cornerstone in the music festival in Gangwon Province  that the dynamic Ms. Woo founded and where Shattered Glass will also perform.

Shattered Glass is a promising ensemble. With a core of such talented and enthusiastic young players, the future should be bright. With the growing popularity of such groups with similar missions, such as Brooklyn Rider and Alarm Will Sound, there is every reason to believe that Shattered Glass will enjoy commercial and artistic success. I look forward to hearing them again in the future.

Share

Orrett Rhoden, Piano

Orrett Rhoden, piano
Zankel Hall at Carnegie Hall, New York, NY
October 15, 2009

Sometimes an encore can leave a more marked impression on an audience than the program itself, and such was the case with Jamaican pianist Orrett Rhoden’s transcription of the Bob Marley song, “One Love.” A reggae-meets-Liszt fusion of his homeland’s music with his own Romantic pianism, it exemplified Mr. Rhoden’s charismatic and communicative gifts. Indeed, these gifts were present throughout the recital, but there were some issues that detracted.

While some of the liberties Mr. Rhoden took may be chalked up to interpretive license, many of them were too much for this listener. Especially in the Sonata, Op. 53 of Beethoven (“Waldstein”) and Schumann’s Etudes Symphoniques, Op. 13, there were myriad grand ritardandi, puzzling tempo changes, dramatic bursts (where more measured dynamics were called for), and changed or added notes that did not enhance the score. While these “personal touches” may be preferable to having no reactions to the score whatsoever (an all too common occurrence), too many of them can distort the music. As just a few examples, in Schumann’s Etude II, grace notes were added in the wrong places and a gratuitous final C-sharp spoiled its character; moreover, the first and second endings of Variation XI had a different bass line than what is written (accentuated, to boot). One could be impressed at times that Mr. Rhoden simply follows his own drummer, as in Etude X, where his added left hand octaves hearkened back to some Romantic piano greats; unfortunately, though, some of these “liberties” must be considered errors, such as in the Finale where the last sixteenths of many measures were changed to eighths, completely changing the rhythmic energy.

The balance of the program included two Scarlatti Sonatas in A Major (L. 483 and 345),

Granados “Allegro de Concierto,” and Chopin’s Scherzo No. 2 in B-flat minor. While in the Granados, one missed the serene mastery of the recently departed Alicia de Larrocha, Rhoden’s characteristic freedom and cantabile phrasing brought some great moments to the Chopin. An encore, the Allemande from Bach’s French Suite in G Major, was followed by the Marley, which brought the house down.

Share